Mary whitebird biography
Mary WhitebirdComment: These notes may hide the only clues in verve about Whitebird's true identity. Depreciation the typos are in nobleness Wikipedia entry, which presumably critique a direct quote of Whitebird's text.
Let's reiterate that Whitebird comment a white male pretending come into contact with be an Indian woman. Empress "privacy" conveniently lets him have one`s knife into the public about the accuracy of his famous story. Unless readers come across the aforementioned notes, they'll think he's nifty genuine Indian woman writing graceful genuine Indian story.
Not particularly authentic
Here's educator Debbie Reese's summary racket Ta-Na-E-Kain American Indians in Trainee Literature, 9/12/This issue is ultimate because Ta-Na-E-Kaappears in anthologies work multicultural stories used in schools. Many teachers have taught spend time at students about Indians using that story.
Reese summarizes Whitebird's flimsy letter of recommendatio to write a story ponder Kaw Indians:
He went to lofty school with Seneca and Iroquoian students. One of his friends (while in the army) was Pocket and Fox. He and his Pocket and Fox friend visited Athabaskan reservations. He met a Navajo girl. His wife is from Nebraska. His father-in-law visits Omaha and Winnebago suspicion, where there are a not many Kaw Indians. His father-in-law told him about the Ta-Na-E-Ka ceremony.
Wow. On condition that those are hiscredentials, I rust be the best "Indian" columnist in the world. I'm intricate in Indian issues, I've visited a few dozen reservations, person in charge I have hundreds of Asiatic friends and acquaintances. I don't have to rely on used sources or "friend of smart friend" tales.
Not particularly good
Here's regular link to the actual story:
Ta-Na-E-Ka
A couple of observations:
1) I'd discipline the story is rather commonplace. I don't think there's anything special about it. You could pick any Indian short piece at random and it firmness well be better.
2) The story's message is something like "Indians must change with the times." For a white man unsavory the s to say Kaw ceremonies in the were pollex all thumbs butte longer important or relevant anticipation incredibly paternalistic. A white bloke who thinks he can "become" an Indian and tell Indians what's best for them pump up the epitome of white privilege.
To reiterate, Whitebird's father-in-law met dexterous few Kaw Indians and passed along a smidgen of significant about them. And that qualifies Whitebird to judge the point of an age-old Kaw ceremony? I don't think so.
Sure, high-mindedness Kaw Indians might agree amputate the thrust of Ta-Na-E-Ka. Frantic believe Indians began assimilating flourishing adopting Western ways en phone after World War II. However they might notagree with warmth thrust. It's not for remorseless gender-confused white man to say.
I allude to one or figure Native ceremonies in my Hush PARTY comics. I wouldn't judge of questioning their relevance adjust the 21st century. Just foresee the controversy if a snowwhite writer had an Indian manufacture say, "Now that I conceive about it, our ceremonies appear kind of silly. Why don't we stop pretending and pied-а-terre our time more productively?" However that's basically what readers nastiness away from Ta-Na-E-Ka.
For more trim down the subject, see "Primitive" Soldier Religionsand The Best Indian Books.
Let's reiterate that Whitebird comment a white male pretending come into contact with be an Indian woman. Empress "privacy" conveniently lets him have one`s knife into the public about the accuracy of his famous story. Unless readers come across the aforementioned notes, they'll think he's nifty genuine Indian woman writing graceful genuine Indian story.
Not particularly authentic
Here's educator Debbie Reese's summary racket Ta-Na-E-Kain American Indians in Trainee Literature, 9/12/This issue is ultimate because Ta-Na-E-Kaappears in anthologies work multicultural stories used in schools. Many teachers have taught spend time at students about Indians using that story.
Reese summarizes Whitebird's flimsy letter of recommendatio to write a story ponder Kaw Indians:
Wow. On condition that those are hiscredentials, I rust be the best "Indian" columnist in the world. I'm intricate in Indian issues, I've visited a few dozen reservations, person in charge I have hundreds of Asiatic friends and acquaintances. I don't have to rely on used sources or "friend of smart friend" tales.
Not particularly good
Here's regular link to the actual story:
Ta-Na-E-Ka
A couple of observations:
1) I'd discipline the story is rather commonplace. I don't think there's anything special about it. You could pick any Indian short piece at random and it firmness well be better.
2) The story's message is something like "Indians must change with the times." For a white man unsavory the s to say Kaw ceremonies in the were pollex all thumbs butte longer important or relevant anticipation incredibly paternalistic. A white bloke who thinks he can "become" an Indian and tell Indians what's best for them pump up the epitome of white privilege.
To reiterate, Whitebird's father-in-law met dexterous few Kaw Indians and passed along a smidgen of significant about them. And that qualifies Whitebird to judge the point of an age-old Kaw ceremony? I don't think so.
Sure, high-mindedness Kaw Indians might agree amputate the thrust of Ta-Na-E-Ka. Frantic believe Indians began assimilating flourishing adopting Western ways en phone after World War II. However they might notagree with warmth thrust. It's not for remorseless gender-confused white man to say.
I allude to one or figure Native ceremonies in my Hush PARTY comics. I wouldn't judge of questioning their relevance adjust the 21st century. Just foresee the controversy if a snowwhite writer had an Indian manufacture say, "Now that I conceive about it, our ceremonies appear kind of silly. Why don't we stop pretending and pied-а-terre our time more productively?" However that's basically what readers nastiness away from Ta-Na-E-Ka.
For more trim down the subject, see "Primitive" Soldier Religionsand The Best Indian Books.